In October, the median single-family sale price in Teller County was $439,500. A year earlier it was $515,000, so the median fell 14.7% in twelve months. Over the first ten months of the year, the county median went from $505,000 in 2025 to $500,000 in 2026, a change of 1.0%. Both figures are in the same Colorado Association of REALTORS October 2026 report for Teller County, and both are accurate. For buyers comparing Woodland Park with towns below the pass, the 1.0% figure says more about prices.
These statistics cover all of Teller County, Woodland Park's home county, and they come out every month. The price numbers have changed less this fall than the headline suggests. The supply numbers have changed more: fewer homes are coming up for sale than a year ago.
Why one month's median moves so much up the pass
Teller County closed 54 single-family sales in October 2026. A median from 54 sales depends on which homes happened to close that month. A handful of lower-priced homes can pull it down, and a handful of larger homes on acreage can push it up, with no change in what any one house is worth.
The last three months show how far it swings. The Teller County median was $475,000 in August, $545,000 in September and $439,500 in October. That is a $105,500 range in ninety days, and September's figure was only 0.9% below September 2025's. Sales ran from 44 to 61 a month over that stretch. The report itself notes, under its tables, that "activity for one month can sometimes look extreme due to small sample size."
Last winter had a similar drop. The Teller County median for January 2026 was $434,500, compared with $518,950 in January 2025. In February it was $477,000. By August, the year-to-date median was $500,000, up 0.1% from the year before. The January drop looked as large as October's, and the year still came out flat.
Other October numbers point the same way. Sellers received 98.2% of list price in October 2026, slightly more than the 97.8% of October 2025. Days on market until sale was 66 in both Octobers. If prices were falling across the board, sellers would be taking deeper discounts and waiting longer, and neither happened.
The number that did change is how many homes are for sale
Teller County had 332 single-family homes for sale at the end of October 2026, compared with 413 a year earlier, a 19.6% drop. Sixty-nine new listings came on in October, down from 101 in October 2025.
This is not a one-month result. Inventory was down 15.9% from a year earlier in August and 19.7% in September. Fewer homes are listed while buyers keep buying at about the same pace. Through October, 556 single-family homes had sold in Teller County in 2026, compared with 548 over the same months of 2025.
Months of supply puts the two together. It estimates how long the homes for sale would last at the current pace of sales. In Teller County it fell from 7.6 months in October 2025 to 5.9 in October 2026. The decline was already under way in August, when it fell from 8.5 to 6.6, and in September, when it fell from 8.2 to 6.3. A year ago, a buyer shopping Teller County had more homes to choose from. This fall the county's inventory is about a fifth smaller, and buyers are closing on homes at the same pace.
How this compares with El Paso County
Many buyers looking at Woodland Park are also looking at Colorado Springs, Monument or Manitou Springs, so the El Paso County numbers for the same month help. Its October 2026 single-family median was $479,000, up 0.8% from a year earlier. Its year-to-date median through October was $487,940, down 0.9%. Inventory was 3,564 homes, up 1.1%, and months of supply was 4.3. Days on market rose from 51 to 56.
Three things stand out. First, through October the typical Teller County home sold for about the same as the typical El Paso County home, $500,000 compared with $487,940 year to date. October's lower Teller figure does not mean living up the pass costs less. Second, Teller County still has more homes for sale relative to its pace of sales, 5.9 months of supply compared with 4.3. Third, the two counties are moving in opposite directions. El Paso County's inventory edged up and its homes are taking longer to sell. Teller County's inventory is falling.
So a buyer who widens a Colorado Springs search to Teller County will find somewhat more choice relative to sales. That gap is narrower than it was a year ago. If you are working through the Colorado Springs side as well, our look at why so many Colorado Springs listings are cutting price covers price cuts there.
What last winter suggests for the next few months
Heading into the winter months, last year's November through February reports for Teller County are a reasonable guide to the season.
| Month | New listings | Sold | Median price | % of list received | Days on market | Inventory | Months supply |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 2025 | 40 | 54 | $514,900 | 96.9% | 62 | 339 | 6.3 |
| Dec 2025 | 36 | 62 | $471,500 | 97.1% | 97 | 251 | 4.5 |
| Jan 2026 | 79 | 42 | $434,500 | 99.0% | 95 | 250 | 4.6 |
| Feb 2026 | 91 | 45 | $477,000 | 97.2% | 105 | 245 | 4.4 |
Last winter shows three patterns. New listings were lowest in November and December, at 40 and 36. Then January and February brought 79 and 91, about twice as many. Inventory fell by about 90 homes between November and December and stayed near 250 through February. Days on market rose to between 95 and 105 days from December through February, and sellers received the smallest share of list price in November and December, 96.9% and 97.1%.
This year starts from a smaller base. Teller County's 332 homes for sale at the end of October 2026 is already fewer than the 339 listed at the end of November 2025. If this winter's listings slow the way last winter's did, Teller County's inventory in December could drop below last year's level.
For a buyer, the season divides into two parts. In November and December, there are the fewest new homes to see, but the homes that have been listed for a while are where sellers last year accepted the most below list price. In January and February, many more new listings arrive, and that is when choice comes back. Your timeline decides which part fits better. A household with a spring military move date, for example, may want to see the January listings. A buyer who has already found the right street may do better with a home that has been listed since fall.
Short answers to questions buyers ask
Did Woodland Park home values drop 15% this year? The county figures do not show that. The 14.7% drop is October 2026 compared with October 2025, based on 54 sales. The Teller County median for January through October 2026 was $500,000, 1.0% below the same period of 2025.
When will the November numbers come out? Last year's November report for Teller County was current as of December 3, 2025, so the November 2026 figures should come out in early December.
Should I watch the median price or the inventory? Watch both, but read the median over several months and pay attention to inventory every month. Teller County's inventory has been 16% to 20% below the previous year in each report from August through October 2026. Over the same stretch, the monthly median swung up and down without a clear direction.
For a sense of daily life beyond the numbers, our Woodland Park neighborhood page and our piece on the three new kitchens on and around Center Street show what the town is like this year.
If you are planning a winter or spring move up the pass, Colorado's Choice Homes can go through each month's Teller County report with you as it comes out and help you decide whether a December offer or January's new listings fits your timeline better. We're available nights and weekends, including for military families on a PCS schedule. Already own in Woodland Park and wondering what fewer competing listings mean for your home? Start with a free home valuation or ask us for a relocation plan.